report here an interesting article last-minute ......
Alternate rankings into chaos. See the ball and Gelmini
The Constitutional Court declared illegal the provision that prevented the precarious South to keep their score if they change their province. Coming Soon thousands of complaints and claims to the Ministry of
EXCEPT Intravaia
block the road to an alternate who is to be inserted in the list only because in Varese was born in Trapani is unconstitutional. This was stated by the Constitutional Court, in rejecting the rules of the Department of Education lists the "tail" of the temporary school. Italy is one and the qualifications have the same value throughout the country, explains the Consulta. A truth that seemed obvious to most, but not to the Gelmini, driven by the League in 2009, worked a kind of protection on the lists of deputies of the school in favor of prof north.
Through a rather complex parliamentary process of Decree-Law entitled "Urgent provisions to ensure continuity of service and education for school year 2009-2010, the government in the conversion The law introduced a paragraph which in fact reinforced the rankings of the regions of the Po, promoting and placing supply teachers in the role with a minimum score to native teachers. "The operations of integration and updating of the lists - says the offending paragraph - is it possible for teachers who require them explicitly, as well as staying in the province (...), chosen to be included also in the rankings of other provinces after the 'last position (third) band in the same rankings.
Outside gobbledygook, the law stated that in the case of the rankings for the years 2009/2010 and 2010/2011 school who was part of a provincial candidate for substitutes and half of the entries in the role laid down annually could not move with their score in another province, if not "queued". And do not "comb" (according to the score gained) as advocated concerned. The rule, as shown by the latest data published by the Ministry, in fact, "protect" the northern alternates.
But now the judges of the Palazzo Spada argue that the article in question "is at odds with the art. 3 of the Constitution." Even the judges of the Lazio Regional Administrative Court had considered the law contrary to a fundamental principle of our legal system: the equality of all citizens. The measure "would violate art. 3 of the Constitution because, in unreasonably e in violazione del principio di uguaglianza, prevede una diversa disciplina a seconda del momento in cui il docente chiede il trasferimento da una graduatoria provinciale ad un'altra", scrivevano i giudici del Tar Lazio.
"La disposizione impugnata - spiegavano i giudici amministrativi - introduce una disciplina irragionevole che limitata all'aggiornamento delle graduatorie e comporta il totale sacrificio del principio del merito posto a fondamento della procedura di reclutamento dei docenti e con la correlata esigenza di assicurare, per quanto più possibile, la migliore formazione scolastica".
La sentenza non mancherà di produrre ricadute politiche e economiche. Il Carroccio si batte da anni per una normativa "di favore" nei confronti degli insegnanti del nord, che però il governo non è riuscito ad assicurare. E il ministero, a questo punto, verrà quasi certamente travolto da migliaia di richieste di risarcimento danni da parte di coloro che si sono visti soffiare per due anni incarichi e immissioni in ruolo. L'Anief (l'Associazione nazionale insegnanti ed educatori in formazione), nel ricordare di avere patrocinato i ricorsi che hanno portato alla bocciatura della norma, vede all'orizzonte 15 mila ricorrenti che possono reclamare il ruolo".
"A questo punto - dichiara il presidente nazionale dell'Anief, Marcello Pacifico, il ministro Gelmini dovrebbe prendere atto di non essere stata capace di gestire le graduatorie del personale docente, dovrebbe take responsibility for having created a profound loss of revenue to state coffers and remedy the position of the applicants with the right, without taking anything away from the teachers already identified in the contracts, as per current practice. "" The attempt of the center, headed by the minister Gelmini, to create a true 'Gothic Line' which would prevent, as strongly advocated by the Northern League, the mobility of teachers within the national territory has failed, "said Tonino Russo (Pd), a member of the Cultural Committee of the Chamber of Deputies.
" The ruling will have devastating effects - continues Russian - and the administration will be forced to take all those teachers who, placed in the queue, in additional lists, we would be in a good position for release in part. "" The minister Gelmini - ends - was in its time and in several occasions, faced with the obvious unreasonableness of the rule, unfortunately not care if they have soundly do with anything but institutional and devoid of common sense, exposing the administration to a huge loss of revenue. "
(February 9, 2011 - The Republic)
0 comments:
Post a Comment